Since Richie filled in for Casey and offered his opinion on the Brett Favre saga, I figured I would do the same thing. After nearly a three month hiatus, I am returning to the Sports Xtra blog forum as Q2’s “guest blogger.”
Brett Favre is without question a first ballot hall of famer and one of the most entertaining athletes the NFL has ever seen. His passion and love for the game continually made him a fan favorite. Favre holds almost all of the meaningful career records for quarterbacks and has started the last 253 regular season games he played in, making him the most durable quarterback in NFL history. At age 38, Favre’s 2007 season will go down as one of his best, but Green Bay’s season ended on a Brett Favre interception.
Now, in mid-July, Favre is contemplating un-retirement, just as he predicted he would during his retirement press conference. He has always had the desire to play on Sundays; it is the rest of the week that led to his retirement. On Sundays, Brett Favre is still one of the top quarterbacks in the game, but Packer management appears to be ready to move forward into the Aaron Rodgers era. Favre has asked for his release, which, understandably, has raised eyebrows around the sports world.
Fans and experts alike are wondering the same things: If Favre comes back, where will it be? If it’s not Green Bay, will it be the same? Is he 100 percent committed? How much does he have left? I am going to tackle these questions in reverse order, culminating with my answer to, “Where will Brett Favre play in 2008?”
How much does Brett Favre have left in the tank?
Athletically, Favre isn’t the same quarterback he was five years ago, but he is much smarter and much more careful with the ball than he was earlier in his career. He still has the arm strength to play in the West Coast offense that doesn’t ask a quarterback to make many deep throws. He still has the durability, resiliency, and competitiveness to play every Sunday. Brett Favre still has gas left in the tank, and I’m not going to say he’s on empty until we see it.
Is Favre 100 percent committed to be a starting NFL quarterback?
Simply put, I don’t think so. I said earlier that on Sundays, Favre will be there, and his team will be able to count on him. He still enjoys playing the game and will lay it all on the line to help his team win. However, he retired and said he doesn’t want to put his body through training camp and practice. That says he lacks 100 percent commitment, but one day a week, he will show up at the stadium and be ready to go.
If Favre returns to the NFL, will it be with Green Bay? If not, how will it affect his legacy?
If he returns, it should be with Green Bay, but I’m not so sure it will be. Favre and Packer management are at odds right now, making this reunion unlikely. Things can change in a hurry, though, if Aaron Rodgers struggles in training camp or goes down with a preseason injury. Green Bay is not ready to move forward with Brian Brohm as their quarterback, so Favre could hear his number called if something happens to Rodgers.
There are only a couple of other options out there for Favre: Atlanta, Baltimore, Carolina, Miami, Tampa Bay, and Washington. Minnesota is not an option. Green Bay won’t let it happen, and I honestly don’t think the Vikings are that interested. You can probably count out Atlanta and Miami if Favre wants to win. Washington looks like they’re ready to continue the Jason Campbell era, leaving Favre’s options as Baltimore, Carolina, and Tampa Bay. Of those three, Tampa Bay makes the most sense from a football standpoint. They run a West Coast offense, coach Jon Gruden collects quarterbacks, and, with Favre, are a Super Bowl contender. Unfortunately, I have to agree with Richie and say Tampa is a good fit. However, I doubt it happens. If Favre returns, it will be in Packer green and gold.
Wednesday, July 16, 2008
Monday, July 14, 2008
Brett Favre Comeback???
Q2's Richie Melby here filling in for Casey with a hot sport topic in the world right now. You can admit it, you're sick of hearing about Brett Favre and this potential comeback. I have always been a Brett Favre fan but the whole retire and un-retire thing is a little ridiculous. It reminds me of a great former NBA player who thought it was time to hang up the shoes but wasn't quite ready to go. The media makes a huge frenzy about stories like this to the point where the actual significance of the story is no longer present.
But enough ranting...let's get down to business. As a Tampa Bay Bucs fan (don't even ask) I'm more than welcome to the idea that we're a possible front runner in the Favre saga. To see Brett behind center in a Tampa Bay uniform would make my day (not that we need anymore QB's but don't get me started on that). Anyways the real question here is what do you all think? We want to hear your take about the Brett Favre comeback; whether you think he should stay retired, play for the Packers, be traded to a new team, or whatever. Just respond to this blog with your thoughts or suggestions about #4 and his return. No matter where you stand it sure is making for an interesting off-season.
Tuesday, July 1, 2008
On the Trail: Back at Home (after some issues)
Mustangs fans, we made it back to Billings. After 5 days of On the Trail with the Mustangs, their 14 game road trip came to a halt after a big win over the Voyagers. Then it was time for the long, late bus ride back to Billings. I know that the players were excited to get back (mostly to play in front of a home crowd, but I understand that some players' girlfriends are coming to Billings so that adds to their excitement!) If you haven't checked out the coverage from this final day (On the Trail: Mustangs ready for Billings home games), make sure and look it up on the website. The Mustangs were very relaxed as I interviewed them today and their answers were pretty amusing. I think they were pumped up to beat Great Falls and enter their Billings homestand on a high note.
Tomorrow night's game is going to be awesome so make sure you come and check it out. I'll be out there with a camera so come up and say hello! I just might get you on camera and throw you on the news. Also don't forget to send all of the pictures you take of yourself, friends, and family to www.ktvq.com so we can put them on our Dehler Park website. Go crazy with those cameras people. It's your chance for your work to be seen by us. I'm excited to see what kind of pictures you guys come up with so make sure and send them all to us.
Tonight's return home got interesting for Kyle and I. About the time we reached Ryegate, maybe a little passed there, we ran into a little trouble. We were playing a music trivia game where we had to come up with Hit songs from the 90's (such as The Boy is Mine by Brandy and Monica) DON'T LAUGH IT WAS KEEPING US AWAKE AND ALERT!!! All of a sudden Bambi and his mother darted across the road and I was driving and forced to slam on the brakes. I went into the left lane to avoid hitting the mother and ended up clipping Bambi and tearing off a piece of our Jeep's bumper. Could have been much worse but still what an ending to our roadtrip!
We got back into the station a little before Jennifer and Rob showed up for the morning show. Make sure and check out all of Montana This Morning in about an hour and a half. Also for all of the latest coverage on the Mustangs continue to log onto the website and stay tuned to the 5:30 and 10 news where we will welcome the Mustangs into their new home at Dehler Park. Hope you all liked our coverage from On The Trail with the Mustangs. See you at Dehler Park in about 14 hours!!
-Richie
Tomorrow night's game is going to be awesome so make sure you come and check it out. I'll be out there with a camera so come up and say hello! I just might get you on camera and throw you on the news. Also don't forget to send all of the pictures you take of yourself, friends, and family to www.ktvq.com so we can put them on our Dehler Park website. Go crazy with those cameras people. It's your chance for your work to be seen by us. I'm excited to see what kind of pictures you guys come up with so make sure and send them all to us.
Tonight's return home got interesting for Kyle and I. About the time we reached Ryegate, maybe a little passed there, we ran into a little trouble. We were playing a music trivia game where we had to come up with Hit songs from the 90's (such as The Boy is Mine by Brandy and Monica) DON'T LAUGH IT WAS KEEPING US AWAKE AND ALERT!!! All of a sudden Bambi and his mother darted across the road and I was driving and forced to slam on the brakes. I went into the left lane to avoid hitting the mother and ended up clipping Bambi and tearing off a piece of our Jeep's bumper. Could have been much worse but still what an ending to our roadtrip!
We got back into the station a little before Jennifer and Rob showed up for the morning show. Make sure and check out all of Montana This Morning in about an hour and a half. Also for all of the latest coverage on the Mustangs continue to log onto the website and stay tuned to the 5:30 and 10 news where we will welcome the Mustangs into their new home at Dehler Park. Hope you all liked our coverage from On The Trail with the Mustangs. See you at Dehler Park in about 14 hours!!
-Richie
Monday, June 30, 2008
On The Trail: Final Game Pre-Day
Hello Mustangs fans, Richie coming to you on our final day of On the Trail with the Mustangs. Their 14 game road trip is finally coming to a halt after tonight's Game 3 with the Great Falls Voyagers. I know these guys are excited to get to Billings. They're a little tired from the long days on the road and in the heat (it's about 92 degrees right now from what I'm told). I just got to the field and am waiting for the team to arrive so I can get those last interviews from them and we'll send them your way for Scott to report on the news.
After the game tonight we'll be making the drive back to Billings where hopefully we can get the Mustangs arriving at Dehler Park (Check out our Dehler web site) so we can see their first reaction of being in Billings and seeing their home field. More on that on Montana This Morning tomorrow.
Anyways log back on after awhile and we'll have all of the latest pictures from life on the road. Until then I either need to find some suntan lotion or get in the shade.
-Richie
After the game tonight we'll be making the drive back to Billings where hopefully we can get the Mustangs arriving at Dehler Park (Check out our Dehler web site) so we can see their first reaction of being in Billings and seeing their home field. More on that on Montana This Morning tomorrow.
Anyways log back on after awhile and we'll have all of the latest pictures from life on the road. Until then I either need to find some suntan lotion or get in the shade.
-Richie
Here are some pics of the Sunday night's light malfunction at Dehler: 
Sunday, June 29, 2008
On The Trail: No Habla Espanol
Well what can I say? I've spent the past 4 days with the Mustangs; hanging around them, listening and talking with them and so on. Today I decided to get to know some of the Spanish speaking players and all I can say is that the 3 years of Spanish I took in school was time well wasted. I couldn't keep up or understand hardly anything they were saying. If you haven't already seen the story make sure and check it out. I had to find out about the challenges that occur between the Americans and the foreign players. How do they hang out and talk with one another? What do they talk about? All that good stuff. Most of the players speak at least a little bit of English so it works out alright. The American players try to pick up on Spanish but most of them have no idea what they're actually saying. It was fun looking into that aspect of the team.
The weather has been RIDICULOUSLY hot up here in Great Falls (as well as everywhere else). Alot of the players and staff have been saying that this is nothing compared to where they come from. And since many of them reside in Texas, Puerto Rico, Venezuela, etc...I think they know what actual heat is like. Still if I get sunburned any worse it may cause some problems.
Only one more road game to go and I'm hearing that Dehler Park was having issues with the lights tonight. Well I hope they get that all worked out by Tuesday because the Mustangs are growing more and more excited to get back to Dehler and play. Might be difficult to play a game when it gets dark and the lights aren't working correctly. I'm sure they'll get it all figured out and Tuesday's home game will be good for the community.
If you haven't already, make sure to check out the latest Exclusive stories we have posted on the website. There's some pretty good stuff on there including the story on Ed Cohen, the play by play radio guy, sneak peeks at life in the dugout, and of course everything else we have done so far on this trip. I'll be back tomorrow with more updates. Have a good night.
-Richie
(PS special shout out tonight to Stef and Courtney. Courtney for hanging out even though she has to be up at 5AM tomorrow and Stef for putting up with me and my field producer, Kyle. Thanks ladies. You're the best!!)
The weather has been RIDICULOUSLY hot up here in Great Falls (as well as everywhere else). Alot of the players and staff have been saying that this is nothing compared to where they come from. And since many of them reside in Texas, Puerto Rico, Venezuela, etc...I think they know what actual heat is like. Still if I get sunburned any worse it may cause some problems.
Only one more road game to go and I'm hearing that Dehler Park was having issues with the lights tonight. Well I hope they get that all worked out by Tuesday because the Mustangs are growing more and more excited to get back to Dehler and play. Might be difficult to play a game when it gets dark and the lights aren't working correctly. I'm sure they'll get it all figured out and Tuesday's home game will be good for the community.
If you haven't already, make sure to check out the latest Exclusive stories we have posted on the website. There's some pretty good stuff on there including the story on Ed Cohen, the play by play radio guy, sneak peeks at life in the dugout, and of course everything else we have done so far on this trip. I'll be back tomorrow with more updates. Have a good night.
-Richie
(PS special shout out tonight to Stef and Courtney. Courtney for hanging out even though she has to be up at 5AM tomorrow and Stef for putting up with me and my field producer, Kyle. Thanks ladies. You're the best!!)
The Rundown
Ed Cohen invited me up to the skybox as he announced the play-by-play live for the Billings radio listeners. Thanks again Ed!I will have a web exclusive story on Ed on KTVQ.COM's Mustangs page later this week!
I also shot video of some of the team's Latin-American players trying to master another game that the Great Falls ball club uses for promotions between innings.... (Click here to play online)
Here are two pics of the team: Pitchers have thier meeting with Tom and Tony works with the guys on their swing (Best to stay behind the netting) 
Saturday, June 28, 2008
Mustangs ride over to Great Falls' Centene Staduim
The next long bus trip is to the Magic City! As Billings fans await the team's first home game, the boys of summer are focused on winning on the road - here in Great Falls.When we (Field Producer Ricky K and I) first arrived at Centene Park, we met up with our Great Falls sister station's weekend sports caster. KRTV's own Greg Smith.
The whole news team over at "KR" is very accommodating to our needs as we continue to send reports back to Billings for the Q2 Newscast.I was able to catch up with Mustangs Manger Julio Garcia after he shopped online for cross-
trainers and before the team's pre-game conditioning. We already have an interview with Garcia up on our website.As we waited with the team for practice to start, the temperature was reaching near 90! Some of the guys that came up from Florida were saying that it was nice (sans the high humidity). Everybody's favorite European-in-Montana weathercaster, Hedi, reported Saturday that we should expect 93 on Sunday and near 100 on Monday.... Summer finially showed up in Montana. (Click here to view Great Fall's weathercast)
During the game Garcia granted me access the dugout. Now I can show you a new point of view on what it is like to be a Mustang. Kyle was able to grab a shot of me during the second inning.... This will be great for my scrapbooking class.... I mean... show the ladies at the bar.As with every trip from Helena to Great Falls, I continued an American tradition - taking pictures of landmarks from the windshield of a moving car. Here's a pic of the "Sleeping Giant"
On The Trail: Great Falls
Well the Helena stand has come to a close and it's off to Great Falls for the final 3 games before we bring the Mustangs back home to Dehler Park. I am excited to see the ballfield in Great Falls because it is a newer park and Dehler took some ideas from it. Should be interesting.
Not much new on the road, at last night's game I hung out in the press box with Ed Cohen, the voice of the Mustangs, to get a feel for his job and see all that goes into the play by play for the team. Let me just say that being a one man band for an entire baseball game is alot harder than people may think. Stay tuned for a complete story on him.
This afternoon I hope to touch base with Mustangs manager Julio Garcia and let everyone get to know him a little bit. He seems to be a pretty straight forward guy and he definitely knows his baseball. Well I gotta go catch up with the team so I'll post again later with a preview of what's coming up. Special shout out to Matt Bender for keeping us in line.
Not much new on the road, at last night's game I hung out in the press box with Ed Cohen, the voice of the Mustangs, to get a feel for his job and see all that goes into the play by play for the team. Let me just say that being a one man band for an entire baseball game is alot harder than people may think. Stay tuned for a complete story on him.
This afternoon I hope to touch base with Mustangs manager Julio Garcia and let everyone get to know him a little bit. He seems to be a pretty straight forward guy and he definitely knows his baseball. Well I gotta go catch up with the team so I'll post again later with a preview of what's coming up. Special shout out to Matt Bender for keeping us in line.
Friday, June 27, 2008
Update from the Trail
Could it be any hotter outside on this roadtrip? If I'm complaining about the heat I don't know 
how the Mustangs can do it. They're wearing their black uniforms today which has to make it even worse. Not to mention the visitors dugout here in Helena is directly in the sun.
View Larger Map
But enough complaining, it's been a pretty busy day since the last time I checked in with you all. Hope you all got to check out the Mustangs breakfast schedule (all continental breakfast almost all the time). I personally would get sick of eating cereal and hotel bagels, but they didn't seem to mind it.
We had a little bit of time to spare before we headed to the field so Online Guru (and an Artium Baccalaureus of History) Kyle and I went to the Montana History Museum to strengthen our intellect. I've been here before but not since the high school days so it was fun to go see everything again. I was trying to get my picture taken giving 2's but some guy in the background had to ruin it! He needs to shave.
Anyways we got some pitching tips online for all of you pitchers or wannabes out there so make sure and check that out.
Also we have a sneak peek into what goes on in the day of a Mustang. They are constantly doing the same routine (which is a superstitious part of baseball anyways) but starting at breakfast until the time they get back to the hotel after the game it's all pretty much the same thing.
how the Mustangs can do it. They're wearing their black uniforms today which has to make it even worse. Not to mention the visitors dugout here in Helena is directly in the sun.View Larger Map
But enough complaining, it's been a pretty busy day since the last time I checked in with you all. Hope you all got to check out the Mustangs breakfast schedule (all continental breakfast almost all the time). I personally would get sick of eating cereal and hotel bagels, but they didn't seem to mind it.
We had a little bit of time to spare before we headed to the field so Online Guru (and an Artium Baccalaureus of History) Kyle and I went to the Montana History Museum to strengthen our intellect. I've been here before but not since the high school days so it was fun to go see everything again. I was trying to get my picture taken giving 2's but some guy in the background had to ruin it! He needs to shave.Anyways we got some pitching tips online for all of you pitchers or wannabes out there so make sure and check that out.
Also we have a sneak peek into what goes on in the day of a Mustang. They are constantly doing the same routine (which is a superstitious part of baseball anyways) but starting at breakfast until the time they get back to the hotel after the game it's all pretty much the same thing.
On The Trail: Day 2
Hello everyone good Friday morning to you. Richie coming at you from Day 2 of On The Trail with the Billings Mustangs. Yesterday proved to be entertaining as I first met up with the team and got to know a few of them. Hopefully you woke up to watch the Morning Show with Jennifer and Nikki (the 2 coolest people I know). If you did watch then I hope you liked the coverage we brought you of the two Mustangs fans we found at last night's game. We had a little difficulty getting the sound to work when we sent the story back to Billings. There are two channels of audio on our edit machine and for some reason or another, the audio of them cheering didn't go through. But have no fear we are working on it so it will be fixed on the website. 
This morning my fellow colleague Kyle and I woke up and headed to the hotel's continental breakfast where we met up with a few of the Mustangs. Stay tuned for an exclusive with a couple of them on what it's like to be eating out of a hotel on the road. (UPDATED: we have pictures and video of everything) I would personally get tired of eating the same thing every morning but check it out to see their thoughts.
Later this afternoon we hope to continue our tips section (yesterday's batting tips for all you baseball/softball players out there). Today we are looking at grabbing the pitching coach to master the technique of the "perfect pitch". We'll see how that goes. We also hope to look into the jobs of a couple Mustangs that aren't even in uniform. Be on the lookout for that as well.
Make sure to stay tuned to KTVQ and ktvq.com for all of the latest from the road as I will keep you upto date throughout the rest of the day. Until the next blog, have a good day as I continue to Ride the Trail with the Ponies. Later
-Richie
This morning my fellow colleague Kyle and I woke up and headed to the hotel's continental breakfast where we met up with a few of the Mustangs. Stay tuned for an exclusive with a couple of them on what it's like to be eating out of a hotel on the road. (UPDATED: we have pictures and video of everything) I would personally get tired of eating the same thing every morning but check it out to see their thoughts.
Later this afternoon we hope to continue our tips section (yesterday's batting tips for all you baseball/softball players out there). Today we are looking at grabbing the pitching coach to master the technique of the "perfect pitch". We'll see how that goes. We also hope to look into the jobs of a couple Mustangs that aren't even in uniform. Be on the lookout for that as well.
Make sure to stay tuned to KTVQ and ktvq.com for all of the latest from the road as I will keep you upto date throughout the rest of the day. Until the next blog, have a good day as I continue to Ride the Trail with the Ponies. Later
-Richie
Billings Mustangs - Meeting the team / Fans in Helena
Hello sports fans (and anyone else reading this blog)...Richie coming to you from the road as we have finished day 1 of On The Trail with the Mustangs.
Yesterday was a long day, starting at around 6AM to get everything ready and then driving to Helena, but once I met up with the team it's been fun ever since. I got to meet the new manager, Julio Garcia and his staff, as well as most of the players. I can already tell that this team is full of characters and the rest of this roadtrip is going to be a great time. Every Mustang I talked to is counting the days until that home opener at Dehler Park. They also can't wait to meet you the fans when they get back into Billings. Tuesday is going to be an awesome day. 
Aside from the team I also met our Capital correspondent, Anna who has been great in helping out. She has made sure we don't get lost here in Helena as well as helping make sure those of you in Billings get the video of our stories. We would have been lost without her so thank you Anna!
At last night's game we also ran into some Billings natives in Jackie Thomson and Ashley Duncan. Both are Skyview graduates who now live in Helena, but they were at the field to cheer on the hometown Mustangs. 
Talk about dedication! These girls are amazing for letting us interview them and hang out with them during the game. If you watched the Raw Footage of their interview, they didn't know that the new ballpark was named Dehler Park. When I spoke with them later they stated "It will always be Cobb Field in our hearts!" Special thanks and shoutout to Jackie and Ashley for being awesome Mustangs fans.
Talk about dedication! These girls are amazing for letting us interview them and hang out with them during the game. If you watched the Raw Footage of their interview, they didn't know that the new ballpark was named Dehler Park. When I spoke with them later they stated "It will always be Cobb Field in our hearts!" Special thanks and shoutout to Jackie and Ashley for being awesome Mustangs fans.Well that will pretty much do it for Day 1 coverage but stay tuned to the newscasts and the website for all of the latest highlights, stories, interviews, blogs, and exclusive content as I will continue bringing them to you while I follow the trail bringing the Mustangs back home to Dehler Park.
-Richie
Thursday, June 26, 2008
On the Trail with the Billings Mustangs
Hey everyone out there in Internet land! This is Richie Melby blogging from the heart of Montana's government operations - Helena (The basement of the capitol)
As some of you might have seen on the news we are following the Billings Mustangs on their final four road games before they rush the field at Dehler Park.
I will update you daily on this blog and tell you about extended and exclusive footage of your Billings Mustangs available on KTVQ.COM.
I will update you daily on this blog and tell you about extended and exclusive footage of your Billings Mustangs available on KTVQ.COM.
We'll have pics, video and maybe have a baseball professional give you tips for the batting cage.
Log on to KTVQ.COM this weekend to watch the videos!
Sunday, May 25, 2008
Montana Saint
No, this has nothing to do with religion. We are a non-denominational blog. This is in reference to former Griz CB Tuff Harris signing a 3-year contract with the New Orleans Saints.
Harris, who played for the Miami Dolphins in his 1st season last year, actually is in a much better situation in New Orleans because they did not draft a man by the name of Ted Ginn Jr., like the Dolphins, and thus are giving Tuff a chance at the punt return job as well as in the defensive secondary.
Harris must have impressed the Saints a lot in last week's workout because he was given a three-year deal based on limited playing in only one game last season (the Dolphins final game, against the Cincinnati Bengals).
This is very encouraging news for the Colstrip native. Keep an eye on him in preseason. He will definitely see the field in the return game, and we all know Tuff is very capable in that department.
Harris, who played for the Miami Dolphins in his 1st season last year, actually is in a much better situation in New Orleans because they did not draft a man by the name of Ted Ginn Jr., like the Dolphins, and thus are giving Tuff a chance at the punt return job as well as in the defensive secondary.
Harris must have impressed the Saints a lot in last week's workout because he was given a three-year deal based on limited playing in only one game last season (the Dolphins final game, against the Cincinnati Bengals).
This is very encouraging news for the Colstrip native. Keep an eye on him in preseason. He will definitely see the field in the return game, and we all know Tuff is very capable in that department.
Thursday, May 15, 2008
Softball Sportsmanship
Tuesday, April 29, 2008
2008 NFL Draft Recap - Seattle Seahawks
Grade: B
Seattle failed to find a developmental offensive guard in the draft, but they did well to get help along the defensive line. They selected DE Lawrence Jackson (USC) in the first round and Texas A&M defensive tackle Red Bryant in the fourth. Jackson’s performance last season warranted a first round selection, and he should be able to provide a pass rush for the ‘Hawks. Bryant, on the other hand, won’t provide much of a rush, but he should be a good run stopper. With sack artists Patrick Kerney, LeRoy Hill, Julian Peterson, and now, Lawrence Jackson, Bryant doesn’t need to get to the quarterback.
TE John Carlson, Seattle’s second round pick, should be an upgrade over Jeb Putzier. He is a complete tight end and will provide QB Matt Hasselbeck with another target. Seattle got more offensive help in FB Owen Schmitt (West Virginia) and RB Justin Forsett (California). Schmitt is a hardnosed fullback, and his attitude alone will make him an NFL starter. Forsett can develop into a third down, change of pace type of back.
With their final pick, Seattle took the best kicker in the draft in Brandon Coutu from Georgia. Josh Brown left via free agency this offseason, and the Seahawks signed Olindo Mare as a short term fix, but Coutu could be there for the long run. He’s consistent from within 40 yards, has a powerful leg, and can develop into an effective field goal kicker in the NFL.
Seattle failed to find a developmental offensive guard in the draft, but they did well to get help along the defensive line. They selected DE Lawrence Jackson (USC) in the first round and Texas A&M defensive tackle Red Bryant in the fourth. Jackson’s performance last season warranted a first round selection, and he should be able to provide a pass rush for the ‘Hawks. Bryant, on the other hand, won’t provide much of a rush, but he should be a good run stopper. With sack artists Patrick Kerney, LeRoy Hill, Julian Peterson, and now, Lawrence Jackson, Bryant doesn’t need to get to the quarterback.
TE John Carlson, Seattle’s second round pick, should be an upgrade over Jeb Putzier. He is a complete tight end and will provide QB Matt Hasselbeck with another target. Seattle got more offensive help in FB Owen Schmitt (West Virginia) and RB Justin Forsett (California). Schmitt is a hardnosed fullback, and his attitude alone will make him an NFL starter. Forsett can develop into a third down, change of pace type of back.
With their final pick, Seattle took the best kicker in the draft in Brandon Coutu from Georgia. Josh Brown left via free agency this offseason, and the Seahawks signed Olindo Mare as a short term fix, but Coutu could be there for the long run. He’s consistent from within 40 yards, has a powerful leg, and can develop into an effective field goal kicker in the NFL.
2008 NFL Draft Recap - Minnesota Vikings
Grade: B
I think the Vikings were big winners coming out of the 2008 draft. They gave up a lot to get DE Jared Allen, but he is going to have a tremendous impact on this defense. Minnesota didn’t have a first round pick, so their first pick was S Tyrell Johnson (Arkansas State) at pick #43. Johnson was arguably the best safety in the draft and was projected to go in the first round, so this is great value for the Vikes. They added more youth and depth to an already strong secondary, and, next season, Minnesota might just have the best defense in the NFL.
Minnesota only had four other picks, but they made what might be the pick of the draft in John David Booty (QB, USC) in the fifth round. Booty should’ve gone in the third round—there was even talk of him going in the second—so getting him in the fifth is a steal. Tarvaris Jackson hasn’t proven he can be an NFL starting quarterback, so Booty has a chance to come in here and take the job over the next two years.
Minnesota is an ideal situation for a young quarterback. They have a great defense, an excellent rushing attack, and a potentially surprising receiving corps with Bernard Berrian and Sidney Rice (if he continues to develop). This is the perfect situation for Booty, and he has the chance to be a more successful NFL quarterback than fellow USC QB, and current Arizona Cardinals starter, Matt Leinart.
I think the Vikings were big winners coming out of the 2008 draft. They gave up a lot to get DE Jared Allen, but he is going to have a tremendous impact on this defense. Minnesota didn’t have a first round pick, so their first pick was S Tyrell Johnson (Arkansas State) at pick #43. Johnson was arguably the best safety in the draft and was projected to go in the first round, so this is great value for the Vikes. They added more youth and depth to an already strong secondary, and, next season, Minnesota might just have the best defense in the NFL.
Minnesota only had four other picks, but they made what might be the pick of the draft in John David Booty (QB, USC) in the fifth round. Booty should’ve gone in the third round—there was even talk of him going in the second—so getting him in the fifth is a steal. Tarvaris Jackson hasn’t proven he can be an NFL starting quarterback, so Booty has a chance to come in here and take the job over the next two years.
Minnesota is an ideal situation for a young quarterback. They have a great defense, an excellent rushing attack, and a potentially surprising receiving corps with Bernard Berrian and Sidney Rice (if he continues to develop). This is the perfect situation for Booty, and he has the chance to be a more successful NFL quarterback than fellow USC QB, and current Arizona Cardinals starter, Matt Leinart.
2008 NFL Draft Recap - Green Bay Packers
Grade: B-
With GM Ted Thompson drafting, it’s tough to doubt anything the Packers do. They traded out of the first round, so their first pick wasn’t until number 36 overall. They selected Jordy Nelson (WR, Kansas State) as the third wide receiver in the draft. I thought that was a bit high for him, but he fits what Green Bay looks for in wideouts. He’s a big, polished route-runner, so he can contribute right away.
The most interesting picks came in the 2nd and 7th rounds however. The Pack selected quarterbacks in each spot—Brian Brohm (Lousville) in the second, and Matt Flynn (LSU) in the seventh. Both add much needed depth to the Packers’ quarterback situation, and Brohm could push Aaron Rodgers for the starting job in the near future. Flynn has the intangibles to be an NFL leader, and, with some coaching, could end up being a great backup or an adequate starter.
Patrick Lee (CB, Auburn) and Jermichael Finley (TE, Texas) were excellent picks as well. Green Bay selected Lee with their 3rd pick in the second round, and he has a chance to become a solid number two corner for the team. Al Harris and Charles Woodson are getting up there in age, so Green Bay needed to find a corner they can groom for the future.
Finley is not a great blocker for a tight end, but he’s a good receiver. Green Bay let Bubba Franks go this offseason, so they needed to find someone to play behind David Martin. Martin will still be the starter, but Finley could see some time in certain situations and two tight end sets.
With GM Ted Thompson drafting, it’s tough to doubt anything the Packers do. They traded out of the first round, so their first pick wasn’t until number 36 overall. They selected Jordy Nelson (WR, Kansas State) as the third wide receiver in the draft. I thought that was a bit high for him, but he fits what Green Bay looks for in wideouts. He’s a big, polished route-runner, so he can contribute right away.
The most interesting picks came in the 2nd and 7th rounds however. The Pack selected quarterbacks in each spot—Brian Brohm (Lousville) in the second, and Matt Flynn (LSU) in the seventh. Both add much needed depth to the Packers’ quarterback situation, and Brohm could push Aaron Rodgers for the starting job in the near future. Flynn has the intangibles to be an NFL leader, and, with some coaching, could end up being a great backup or an adequate starter.
Patrick Lee (CB, Auburn) and Jermichael Finley (TE, Texas) were excellent picks as well. Green Bay selected Lee with their 3rd pick in the second round, and he has a chance to become a solid number two corner for the team. Al Harris and Charles Woodson are getting up there in age, so Green Bay needed to find a corner they can groom for the future.
Finley is not a great blocker for a tight end, but he’s a good receiver. Green Bay let Bubba Franks go this offseason, so they needed to find someone to play behind David Martin. Martin will still be the starter, but Finley could see some time in certain situations and two tight end sets.
2008 NFL Draft Recap - Denver Broncos
Grade: C+
Denver needed to get two things out of this draft—a left tackle and a defensive tackle. They got both, even though they didn’t draft a defensive tackle - they acquired former first round pick Dewayne Robertson in a trade with the New York Jets. Robertson has underachieved over his career, but he’s a big body who is an upgrade over last year’s defensive tackle rotation.
With their first pick (#12 overall), Denver selected Ryan Clady, OT, Boise State. He was the guy we thought they were targeting all along due to his athleticism and mobility. He is perfect for Denver’s zone blocking scheme and should really help protect Jay Cutler’s blindside.
Denver’s most intriguing picks past round one are Eddie Royal (WR, Virginia Tech), Kory Lichtensteiger (C, Bowling Green), and Ryan Torain (RB, Arizona State). I thought they reached for Royal with Cal’s DeSean Jackson, Oklahoma’s Malcolm Kelly, and Texas’ Limas Sweed all still available. Royal is somewhat raw in his route running, but should provide some explosiveness in the return game. If that’s what they were looking for, though, why not take this draft’s best game-breaker in Jackson?
Lichtensteiger was Denver’s first fourth round pick, and he should provide the offensive line with much needed depth. He doesn’t project as an NFL starter, but he should be able to play in spot duty.
When Denver picks a running back, we always look for him to succeed behind their usually incredible blocking. Torain is a north-south runner, so I’m not sure how well he fits their scheme, but he should be able to make one cut and go. He’s not going to outrun many defenders, but he should be able to break a few tackles and gain some yards after contact.
Denver needed to get two things out of this draft—a left tackle and a defensive tackle. They got both, even though they didn’t draft a defensive tackle - they acquired former first round pick Dewayne Robertson in a trade with the New York Jets. Robertson has underachieved over his career, but he’s a big body who is an upgrade over last year’s defensive tackle rotation.
With their first pick (#12 overall), Denver selected Ryan Clady, OT, Boise State. He was the guy we thought they were targeting all along due to his athleticism and mobility. He is perfect for Denver’s zone blocking scheme and should really help protect Jay Cutler’s blindside.
Denver’s most intriguing picks past round one are Eddie Royal (WR, Virginia Tech), Kory Lichtensteiger (C, Bowling Green), and Ryan Torain (RB, Arizona State). I thought they reached for Royal with Cal’s DeSean Jackson, Oklahoma’s Malcolm Kelly, and Texas’ Limas Sweed all still available. Royal is somewhat raw in his route running, but should provide some explosiveness in the return game. If that’s what they were looking for, though, why not take this draft’s best game-breaker in Jackson?
Lichtensteiger was Denver’s first fourth round pick, and he should provide the offensive line with much needed depth. He doesn’t project as an NFL starter, but he should be able to play in spot duty.
When Denver picks a running back, we always look for him to succeed behind their usually incredible blocking. Torain is a north-south runner, so I’m not sure how well he fits their scheme, but he should be able to make one cut and go. He’s not going to outrun many defenders, but he should be able to break a few tackles and gain some yards after contact.
Saturday, April 26, 2008
Montana Draft Prospects
There are several UM and MSU players that have entered this year's NFL Draft, but only two that have a legitimate shot at hearing their names called in New York - Griz RB Lex Hilliard, and Griz DE Kroy Biermann.
Lex Hilliard: The outstanding Griz running back, Lex Hilliard, might have to learn a new position if and when his name gets called during the NFL draft. Most analysts have Hilliard projected as a fullback, much like Justin Green a few years ago. Hilliard is a 231 pound runner who ran the 40 in the 4.7 range, so he is a bit of a ‘tweener, which hurts his draft stock. He’s too big and a little slow to be an NFL running back, but may be a bit small to play fullback. He’s ideal for short yardage situations, though, because he tends to fall forward when tackled. Yards after contact are probably the most important statistic to runners in the NFL, since it’s a rarity to burst through the line untouched. He has a nose for the endzone (as evidenced by his UM record 49 career rushing touchdowns), but his lack of production in the passing game hurts his stock.
Projection: Hilliard might come off the board late on day two (sixth or seventh round), but it’s more likely that he goes undrafted and signs with a team next week.
Kroy Biermann: Of the Montana draft prospects, Griz defensive end Kroy Biermann has the best shot at being drafted on Sunday. Biermann is a bit undersized to play end in the NFL, which is why most scouts have him projected as a 3-4 rush linebacker. He tested as a defensive end at the combine, but if you compare his numbers to the linebacker class, he does quite well. He is strong (repping 225 pounds nine times) and quick, but he doesn’t have elite top end speed (he ran the 40 in 4.85 seconds). However, with more and more NFL teams implementing a 3-4 defense, a player like Biermann has a chance to get his name called late in the draft.
Projection: The most likely scenario is for Biermann to come off the board in the sixth or seventh round. I’ll go out on a limb and say he gets taken in round six as the only Montana player drafted in 2008.
2008 Montana NFL Draft Prospects
Lex Hilliard: The outstanding Griz running back, Lex Hilliard, might have to learn a new position if and when his name gets called during the NFL draft. Most analysts have Hilliard projected as a fullback, much like Justin Green a few years ago. Hilliard is a 231 pound runner who ran the 40 in the 4.7 range, so he is a bit of a ‘tweener, which hurts his draft stock. He’s too big and a little slow to be an NFL running back, but may be a bit small to play fullback. He’s ideal for short yardage situations, though, because he tends to fall forward when tackled. Yards after contact are probably the most important statistic to runners in the NFL, since it’s a rarity to burst through the line untouched. He has a nose for the endzone (as evidenced by his UM record 49 career rushing touchdowns), but his lack of production in the passing game hurts his stock.
Projection: Hilliard might come off the board late on day two (sixth or seventh round), but it’s more likely that he goes undrafted and signs with a team next week.
Kroy Biermann: Of the Montana draft prospects, Griz defensive end Kroy Biermann has the best shot at being drafted on Sunday. Biermann is a bit undersized to play end in the NFL, which is why most scouts have him projected as a 3-4 rush linebacker. He tested as a defensive end at the combine, but if you compare his numbers to the linebacker class, he does quite well. He is strong (repping 225 pounds nine times) and quick, but he doesn’t have elite top end speed (he ran the 40 in 4.85 seconds). However, with more and more NFL teams implementing a 3-4 defense, a player like Biermann has a chance to get his name called late in the draft.
Projection: The most likely scenario is for Biermann to come off the board in the sixth or seventh round. I’ll go out on a limb and say he gets taken in round six as the only Montana player drafted in 2008.
Thursday, April 24, 2008
Q2 NFL Mock Draft - 1st Round
Hello everybody! Sorry for not posting in a while, but Slim and I have been hard at work on Q2's first NFL Mock Draft. We are here to submit our picks for Saturday's upcoming NFL Draft 1st Round, saying who we think will go at which spot and to which team.
NOTE: We went about this draft without factoring in any draft-day trades that might occur. We understand, and believe, that it will happen, but we cannot predict who will be trading and at what price (which draft picks will go to which teams). Thus, we made these picks with the assumption that each team will stay in its pre-determined spot, and select players with the intention of making their particular team better.
With that said, Slim and I are planning on coming out with a "Draft Day Trade Scenario" post before Saturday's draft kicks off (1:00 PM MST, ESPN), that will detail all the possible trades that could occur, and thus the changes in which players will go where.
So without further ado, I give you Q2's first ever Mock Draft.
1. Miami Dolphins – Jake Long, OT, Michigan
2007 Record (1-15) – Miami has already reached a contract agreement with Long (5 years, $57.75 million with $30 million guaranteed), so he is signed, sealed, and delivered. At this point, announcing his name on Saturday is just a formality. The Dolphins have been saying Long was their guy all along, and he’s a great pick. He has a chance to be the cornerstone left tackle for this struggling franchise for the next ten years.
2. St. Louis Rams – Chris Long, DE, Virginia
2007 Record (3-13) – The Rams face a tough decision between Chris Long and DT Glenn Dorsey, but should go with Long based on his ability to rush the QB. Long, the son of Hall of Fame DE Howie Long, has a special skill set rarely seen from someone right out of college, and can line up at either end position or even outside linebacker. Dorsey also has durability issues, and may not hold up well on the turf of the Edward Jones Dome. Long will use his exceptional quickness to an advantage on the surface, so he should be the choice.
3. Atlanta Falcons – Matt Ryan, QB, Boston College
2007 Record (4-12) - This should be the easiest choice in the top half of the draft. Atlanta’s only star is in jail for the next two years (QB Michael Vick), and the Falcons cannot hope to sell tickets (or win for that matter) with Joey Harrington leading them. Draft Ryan, and hope he turns into your new QB of the future.
4. Oakland Raiders – Darren McFadden, RB, Arkansas
2007 Record (4-12) - While I think the Raiders would be better off addressing a position of more need, it’s hard to argue with selecting maybe the draft’s Most Talented Player. Owner Al Davis is famous for his love of athletic skill players, and “Run DMC” is definitely that. The backfield tandem of McFadden and last year’s #1 overall pick, QB JaMarcus Russell, would be very formidable to opposing defenses.
5. Kansas City Chiefs – Glenn Dorsey, DT, LSU
2007 Record (4-12) – With Tuesday’s trade that sent NFL sack leader Jared Allen to the Vikings, the Chiefs need to bolster their now depleted defensive line. Thus, Dorsey should be the pick. He’s a mammoth DT with great hands, and will be a multiple Pro-Bowler if he can stay healthy. There have been rumors circulating that they would reach for OG Branden Albert here, but Dorsey has too much upside to pass up. Plus, Kansas City now has Minnesota’s first round pick as well (#17), so they can look to add an o-linemen at that spot.
6. New York Jets – Vernon Gholston, DE/OLB, Ohio State
2007 Record (4-12) - The Jets would love it if McFadden fell to them in this spot, and might even trade up to get him. But if they’re forced to stay here, and McFadden is gone, they should take Gholston, a great pass rushing threat in the style of Shawne Merriman. Gholston will bolster a Jets D that ranked near the bottom last season, and should provide an immediate impact.
7. New England Patriots (from San Francisco)
2007 Record (16-0)
NOTE: We went about this draft without factoring in any draft-day trades that might occur. We understand, and believe, that it will happen, but we cannot predict who will be trading and at what price (which draft picks will go to which teams). Thus, we made these picks with the assumption that each team will stay in its pre-determined spot, and select players with the intention of making their particular team better.
With that said, Slim and I are planning on coming out with a "Draft Day Trade Scenario" post before Saturday's draft kicks off (1:00 PM MST, ESPN), that will detail all the possible trades that could occur, and thus the changes in which players will go where.
So without further ado, I give you Q2's first ever Mock Draft.
2008 NFL MOCK DRAFT - ROUND 1
1. Miami Dolphins – Jake Long, OT, Michigan2007 Record (1-15) – Miami has already reached a contract agreement with Long (5 years, $57.75 million with $30 million guaranteed), so he is signed, sealed, and delivered. At this point, announcing his name on Saturday is just a formality. The Dolphins have been saying Long was their guy all along, and he’s a great pick. He has a chance to be the cornerstone left tackle for this struggling franchise for the next ten years.
2. St. Louis Rams – Chris Long, DE, Virginia2007 Record (3-13) – The Rams face a tough decision between Chris Long and DT Glenn Dorsey, but should go with Long based on his ability to rush the QB. Long, the son of Hall of Fame DE Howie Long, has a special skill set rarely seen from someone right out of college, and can line up at either end position or even outside linebacker. Dorsey also has durability issues, and may not hold up well on the turf of the Edward Jones Dome. Long will use his exceptional quickness to an advantage on the surface, so he should be the choice.
3. Atlanta Falcons – Matt Ryan, QB, Boston College2007 Record (4-12) - This should be the easiest choice in the top half of the draft. Atlanta’s only star is in jail for the next two years (QB Michael Vick), and the Falcons cannot hope to sell tickets (or win for that matter) with Joey Harrington leading them. Draft Ryan, and hope he turns into your new QB of the future.
4. Oakland Raiders – Darren McFadden, RB, Arkansas2007 Record (4-12) - While I think the Raiders would be better off addressing a position of more need, it’s hard to argue with selecting maybe the draft’s Most Talented Player. Owner Al Davis is famous for his love of athletic skill players, and “Run DMC” is definitely that. The backfield tandem of McFadden and last year’s #1 overall pick, QB JaMarcus Russell, would be very formidable to opposing defenses.
5. Kansas City Chiefs – Glenn Dorsey, DT, LSU2007 Record (4-12) – With Tuesday’s trade that sent NFL sack leader Jared Allen to the Vikings, the Chiefs need to bolster their now depleted defensive line. Thus, Dorsey should be the pick. He’s a mammoth DT with great hands, and will be a multiple Pro-Bowler if he can stay healthy. There have been rumors circulating that they would reach for OG Branden Albert here, but Dorsey has too much upside to pass up. Plus, Kansas City now has Minnesota’s first round pick as well (#17), so they can look to add an o-linemen at that spot.
6. New York Jets – Vernon Gholston, DE/OLB, Ohio State2007 Record (4-12) - The Jets would love it if McFadden fell to them in this spot, and might even trade up to get him. But if they’re forced to stay here, and McFadden is gone, they should take Gholston, a great pass rushing threat in the style of Shawne Merriman. Gholston will bolster a Jets D that ranked near the bottom last season, and should provide an immediate impact.
7. New England Patriots (from San Francisco)2007 Record (16-0)
- Slim: Leodis McKelvin, CB, Troy
This is the first pick Casey and I disagree on, primarily because we disagree on the Patriots’ needs. After losing Asante Samuel and Randall Gay to free agency, New England needs a corner. McKelvin is arguably the best in the class and has steadily climbed up draft boards. OLB Keith Rivers could be the choice here as LB is also a need, but McKelvin represents better value in the top 7. - Casey: Keith Rivers, OLB, USC
New England plays a base 3-4 defense, meaning they play AT LEAST 4 linebackers on each down. Here is their current starting Linebacking corps (and age): Tedy Bruschi (34), Mike Vrabel (32), Adalius Thomas (30), and Eric Alexander (26). And that doesn’t even mention their top two reserves are 33 and 31. That would all be ok if these guys were Pro-Bowl caliber LB’s…but they’re not. New England not only needs help, but they need a franchise LB that can anchor this unit for years to come. That’s Rivers, a prototypical leader who, at 6’2”, 240 lbs, can play inside or outside, and will always be around the ball.
8. Baltimore Ravens – Sedrick Ellis, DT, USC
2007 Record (5-11) – Baltimore is one team in the draft who definitely should look to trade up. With Steve McNair’s recent retirement, the Ravens are left with Kyle Boller and Troy Smith on their QB depth chart, so trying to grab Boston College’s Matt Ryan would be wise. He shouldn’t fall past Atlanta at 3, though, leaving Baltimore in a tough spot. Sedrick Ellis doesn’t represent the biggest need, but he does represent the best value. Pairing him with Haloti Ngata would give the Ravens one of the best, young defensive tackle tandems in the league.
9. Cincinnati Bengals – Branden Albert, OG/OT, Virginia
2007 Record (7-9) - Albert is flying up draft boards as a versatile O-Lineman who scouts say can play either G or T in the pros. Ideally, Cincinnati will hope that Sedrick Ellis falls to them here, but if he doesn’t, Albert would be a solid pick to bolster a suspect offensive line. Albert’s versatility is what’s making him a potential Top-10 pick.
10. New Orleans Saints
2007 Record (7-9)
- Slim: Keith Rivers, OLB, USC
The Saints’ weakness is their defense, so they will be one of the teams trying to trade up to grab one of the elite defensive tackles. They can look at CB here, but I have LB as a higher need, so Rivers makes the most sense. He is a big, strong ‘backer who is a better leader than player and will provide New Orleans with a good character guy to build their defense around. - Casey: Leodis McKelvin, CB, Troy
Corner is the most intriguing position in this draft. There are four elite guys that could all be the first CB off the board. It all depends on which one is the right fit for each individual team, but I agree with Slim that McKelvin should be rated slightly above the rest. He is the most complete corner of the four at 5'11", 190 lbs, and will also add an explosive return game to New Orleans with his 4.38 speed. No matter the team, McKelvin should be the first corner taken, and in my opinion, that will be New Orleans.
11. Buffalo Bills – Devin Thomas, WR, Michigan State
2007 Record (7-9) - The Bills need a WR bad to draw attention away from Lee Evans and give last year’s second round pick, QB Trent Edwards, another receiving option. Thomas is a reach, but the Bills are reportedly very high on him, and will likely take him at this spot.
12. Denver Broncos – Ryan Clady, OT, Boise State
2007 Record (7-9) - The Broncos O-Line used to be a thing of beauty…maybe the most dominating unit ever in the late-90’s and early 2000’s. That is not the case anymore, and Denver needs to start injecting youth into the lineup. Clady is the perfect fit for the zone-blocking system. He has incredibly quick feet and is extremely agile for his size (6’6 ½”, 310 lbs). If they take him, Clady will be the next franchise Bronco Tackle.
13. Carolina Panthers – Derrick Harvey, DE, Florida
2007 Record (7-9) – Up until Tuesday, OT was Carolina’s biggest need. Then DE Mike Rucker retired. Derrick Harvey will be an excellent complement to Julius Peppers and give the Panthers two potentially great pass rushers. Harvey is a huge DE (6’5”) with a quick first step who should be a very solid rush end at the next level.
14. Chicago Bears – Chris Williams, OT, Vanderbilt
2007 Record (7-9) – The Bears’ biggest need is OT, and Chris Williams is the best on the board. He has good size (6’6”, 315 lbs.) and adequate mobility. Running back is an option, but I don’t think the team is ready to give up on Cedric Benson just yet. Williams should make Benson’s life easier, and, if not, then RB should be addressed next offseason.
15. Detroit Lions – Rashard Mendenhall, RB, Illinois
2007 Record (8-8) – The Lions have been in love with Mendenhall since he announced he was entering the draft, so he will no doubt be the pick here. With last season’s offensive coordinator Mike Martz leaving for San Francisco, the Lions will now go back to a more run-oriented offense. Mendenhall was the only player on Illinois’ team last season that looked like he belonged on the same field as USC during the Rose Bowl. He can be a workhorse-type back and should be able to carry the load for a franchise that has struggled drafting offensive players in the first round in the past.
16. Arizona Cardinals
2007 Record (8-8)
- Slim: Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, CB, Tennessee State
Arizona’s offense is set, and their biggest need on defense is in the secondary. Everything I’ve read suggests Rodgers-Cromartie is their guy. He’s the cousin of San Diego CB Antonio Cromartie, which can’t be a bad thing. Simply put, Rodgers-Cromartie is a playmaker and instantly would improve Arizona’s secondary. - Casey: Mike Jenkins, CB, South Florida
Slim and I agree that the Cardinals with take a CB here…we just disagree on which one it will be. Most draft analysts have Jenkins and Rodgers-Cromartie neck and neck when it comes to talent, so this may come down to the best "system" fit. In my opinion, the Cardinals need a leader in the secondary at corner, a guy that plays with a mean streak and can play bump, zone, and man-to-man coverage. That's Jenkins, the most physical of the four corners. Jenkins has great bulk for his 5'11" frame, and can turn and run with receivers with his 4.38 speed. Jenkins is the more well-rounded of the two, so he should be the pick.
17. Kansas City Chiefs (from Minnesota) – Jeff Otah, OT, Pittsburgh
2007 Record (4-12) – Before last season, Kansas City was *THE* quintessential rushing team in the league over the last 5 years. It all started with Priest Holmes, and never even skipped a beat when Holmes got hurt, and Larry Johnson stepped in. Not to take anything away from those backs, but neither would have the numbers they do if it weren’t for Kansas City’s O-line. Case in Point: Last year, when Johnson averaged only 3.5 yards per carry over the 1st half of the season before getting hurt. With Brodie Croyle still finding his legs as the team’s new QB, the Chiefs need to rebuild the line to become one of the top rushing teams once again. Otah is a big, strong drive-blocker and will be a perfect complement to LT Damian McIntosh on the right side.
18. Houston Texans – Jonathan Stewart, RB, Oregon
2007 Record (8-8) – CB is a bigger need. No denying it. But Houston is better on defense than it is on offense, and in our mind, needs to improve that side of the ball. Stewart is an undersized, but incredibly strong and shifty back who can be a star in this league. He has a great initial burst to get to the second level, and enough quickness to outrun the secondary. His only knock is durability, as he’s been slightly injured at most points during his college career. But Houston should take him to round out a budding offense that could have them challenge for the playoffs this year.
19. Philadelphia Eagles – Limas Sweed, WR, Texas
2007 Record (8-8) – The Eagles need a WR more than any other position. Some will argue that with CB Lito Sheppard asking to be traded, CB is just as big of a need, and thus one of the top four CB’s should go here (best value). But the Eagles spent big money to bring in CB Asante Samuel, maybe the league’s best corner, in the offseason, so they should address a weak WR corps here. Sweed is a reach, but he is the most complete WR with the best chance to develop into a consistent #1 in the league.
20. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Aqib Talib, CB, Kansas
2007 Record (9-7) – The Bucs are in the same boat as Philly, in that CB and WR are the two biggest needs. However, the Bucs still have Joey Galloway, who despite being 34, still is a top 15 receiver, and Michael Clayton, who has the potential to regain his 1200-yd. rookie season form. Thus, it makes more sense to a CB here. On Slim’s board, he has Talib and Mike Jenkins still available, where I have Talib and Rodgers-Cromartie. We both think Talib will be the pick here however, since he is the most athletic of the top four, and has the best chance to score on defense. The Bucs are known for their aggressive D, so they should take the ultra-aggressive Talib, who loves to go for the big play.
21. Washington Redskins – Phillip Merling, DE, Clemson
2007 Record (9-7) – Washington also is in need of a big time WR, but we think Thomas and Sweed, the two most talented guys, will be gone at this point, so they can’t get good enough value. Thus, they should addres another big need at Defensive End. At 6’4 ¼” and 276 lbs, Merling has a great combination of size and strength to go along with his 4.7 speed. He is not spectacular at any one aspect as a DE, but is one of the most well-rounded ends in the draft, and would be very good value here.
22. Dallas Cowboys (from Cleveland) – Felix Jones, RB, Arkansas
2007 Record (13-3) – This pick is the worst kept secret in the draft. Dallas has targeted Felix Jones from the day the junior announced he was entering the draft. Marion Barber III showed he was the best big back in the league last year, and the ultra-quick Jones would be the perfect change-of-pace complement. A no-brainer pick here.
23. Pittsburgh Steelers – Kentwan Balmer, DT, North Carolina
2007 Record (10-6) – The Steelers biggest need is a DE for their 3-4 scheme, and while Balmer played DT in college and is technically more suited to stay there in the pros, he could actually be a solid DE in a 3-4 defense. He has a great initial burst off the line, and can overwhelm guards and tackles with his size and strength from the position (6’4 ½”, 308 lbs).
24. Tennessee Titans – DeSean Jackson, WR, California
2007 Record (10-6) – Tennessee’s biggest needs are WR and now CB, after Wednesday’s trade that sent suspended CB Adam ‘Pacman’ Jones to Dallas. However, the Titans fared fine last season without Jones, so I think adding another weapon for Vince Young is the key. While Young has never been the most accurate thrower, he has a cannon for an arm, and would love to be able to use it. Jackson is a game-changer when he gets the ball in his hands. He is maybe the quickest player in this year’s draft, and would give Tennessee the deep-threat they lack…not to mention fill in for Pacman as a return man, a position he will make the Pro-Bowl from.
25. Seattle Seahawks – Dustin Keller, TE, Purdue
2007 Record (10-6) – In a perfect world, Kentwan Balmer would fall to the Seahawks here. However, the NFL Draft is far from perfect, so with Balmer gone, Seattle will be left to address their most pressing need. The Hawks need pass catchers, both from the WR and TE spot. However, with the development of the TE as an offensive weapon over the past few season (Antonio Gates, Jeremy Shockey, Kellen Winslow, etc.), Keller is the best value here. At 6’2”, 242 lbs, Keller runs a 4.5 40-yard dash, and has unbelievable hands. He will be un-coverable by any NFL linebacker, and will be a huge weapon for Matt Hasslebeck.
26. Jacksonville Jaguars – Lawrence Jackson, DE, USC
2007 Record (11-5) – Jacksonville’s biggest need is along the defensive front, which is why there are many rumors floating around that have Miami DE Jason Taylor heading up the road to the Jags next season. But if that doesn’t happen, they should look to add the top DE still available, which would be Jackson. “Lo-Jack” had the benefit of lining up against All-American tackle Sam Baker in practice and next to Top 10 pick Sedrick Ellis on the D-Line for four years. He’s seen elite competition, and is extremely prepared for the next level.
27. San Diego Chargers
2007 Record (11-5)
- Slim: Gosder Cherilus, OT, Boston College
The Chargers need a right tackle to complement Pro-Bowler Marcus McNeil on the left side, and Cherilus is a perfect fit here. He has a massive frame (6’6 ½”, 314 lbs), and has enormous arms and hands. Thus, he has a great reach and can push around most defensive linemen. He even has a frame to get bigger, which would make him a steal this late. - Casey: Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, CB, Tennessee State
In my scenario, Rodgers-Cromartie is the last of the top four corners still on the board, and the Chargers would be ecstatic if he fell to them. Cromartie ran a 4.33 40-yard dash, and is one of th quickest players in the draft. He has decent size (5’10 ½”) for his speed, and has good ball skills. Thus, he is always a factor to make the big play. Not to mention that he is the cousin of San Diego’ Pro-Bowl CB Antonio Cromartie, who led the league in INT’s last year. That would be too good of a secondary combination to pass up.
28. Dallas Cowboys – Malcolm Kelly, WR, Oklahoma
2007 Record (13-3) – After getting Pacman from Tennessee on Wednesday, and with Commissioner Roger Goddell likely reinstating him before training camp, Dallas no longer needs a corner to play across from Terence Newman. Thus, receiver becomes their top need, as Terry Glenn is getting old and is to injury prone to count on as a viable complement to T.O. Kelly and James Hardy are the best WR’s left, but Kelly, the 6’4”, 225 lb. WR out of Oklahoma, is definitely the more athletic and gifted of the two, so he should be the pick.
29. San Francisco 49ers (from Indianapolis)
2007 Record (5-11)
- Slim: James Hardy, WR, Indiana
Darrell Jackson was not the answer at WR for San Francisco last season, and is now gone. The Niners are now left with a WR core of Arnaz Battle, Ashley Lelie, Bryant Johnson, and Isaac Bruce. Not exactly a fearsome foursome. At 6’6”, Hardy is a huge wideout from Indiana who runs well (4.5) for his size. He would give QB Alex Smith another big target, in addition to last year’s 1st Round choice, TE Vernon Davis, and might finally get this offense rolling. - Casey: Gosder Cherilus, OT, Boston College
The 49ers offensive woes stem from one simple problem: they can’t protect QB Alex Smith. In 6+ games last season, Smith was sacked 17 times, including one that knocked him out for the rest of the season. RT Joe Staley is a solid player, but they would love to get Cherilus here so that they could move Staley to the left (Smith’s blind side) and slide Cherlius in on the right. Cherilus plays with a mean streak, and would form a solid anchor-tandem with Staley. The Niners might then finally score some points.
30. Green Bay Packers
2007 Record (13-3)
- Slim: Mike Jenkins, CB, South Florida
Green Bay’s dream scenario is if one of the top four CB’s falls to them at this spot. And if they had their choice, they would probably like it to be Jenkins above all else. As Casey said earlier, Jenkins is the toughest corner in this class, and would fit very well into the Packers press-coverage scheme. He also ran a sub 4.4 40-yard dash, and has excelled in his limited opportunities in the return game, a position he would no doubt improve for the Pack. - Casey: Brandon Flowers, CB, Virginia Tech
Since none of the ‘Big 4’ are left at this spot, Green Bay will settle for Flowers, a strong, tough corner who would fall in line perfectly behind Charles Woodson and Al Harris. Woodson and Harris make their living in press coverage, bumping and jamming receivers off the line of scrimmage all day. However, they are 31 and 33 years old, respectively, and the Packers need an heir apparent. Flowers is the same type of player, and will transition beautifully.
31. New England Patriots – Pick Forfeited
2007 Record (16-0) – The Patriots lost the 31st overall pick as part of the penalty handed down for illegally videotaping Jets coaches from their sideline in Week 1.
32. New York Giants – Tyrell Johnson, S, Arkansas State
2007 Record (10-6) – The Giants lost FS Gibril Wilson to free agency this offseason, and thus need to find his replacement. S Kenny Phillips (Miami) and Johnson have flip-flopped at this spot for the last two months, but is looks like New York is favoring Johnson as we approach Saturday’s big day. Johnson is a very strong safety. In fact, his 27 reps on the 225-lb. bench press at the combine was the most by any DB. He is not the most athletic, but has adequate speed at 4.55, and good size at 6’0”, 200 lbs to be a solid starter in the league.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)